Wendell Berry and the road to here


I spent a number of years pursuing various advanced degrees. In some ways, my interests were similar to those I have now. I studied anthropology and American culture, with most of my research focused on mass consumer society. My guiding question was how we ended up so alienated from each other and our work, and so attached, in turn, to relatively useless “stuff” that our species never needed prior to 1900 or so. Leaving the university, however, was probably a much bigger step on the road to answering that question for myself. I left because I didn’t want to lead the academic life—roaming the country, following temporary jobs or tenure track positions that could be yanked after six years of investment. I, after my paripatetic childhood, wanted to try living in place.

I’m still working on that—getting closer, though. I ponder this odyssey in thinking about Wendell Berry. Berry, more than all of the social theorists I read in grad school, articulated for me what I had previously only felt about “place.” When I first read him it was with that amazing feeling of gratitude and wonder you get when you realize someone has figured out something fundamental. Someone who can help you find your way.

There’s a great interview with Berry by Thomas Healy on Counterpunch. This excerpt, about abstraction, is so concise and true. I read Wendell Berry and think if I could just get people to listen to what he has to say . . . but Berry’s words are demanding. If you read them with stillness and reflection, you will change how you live.


TH: In your book The Way of Ignorance, there’s an essay “Imagination in Place,” in which you object to “anybody for rating the land as ‘capital’ or its human members as ‘labor.'” Do you find these terms offensive?

WB: The issue is abstraction. The nature of things is that you can’t properly value something on abstract terms. Every parcel of land in the country is a particular place, and you can’t love it or care for it or use it properly in the abstract. To reduce it to money value obscures its existence as a particular good. And when you reduce human beings to an abstraction like “labor” or a “labor force,” you obscure the whole issue of their community membership and their involvement in a particular economy and their particular worth as individual people, individual creatures—that’s what I was saying in that essay. I’m against referring to people as “human resources” because it reduces them to abstract counters like dollar bills. I am insisting that you must not regard your community members as a labor force that is subject to being moved about at the whim of the economy. You must not accept the breakup of community relationships or homes as a normal cost of production. Communities shouldn’t give up their members so easily.

This entry was posted in General., Sustainability.. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Wendell Berry and the road to here

  1. Birdsong says:

    A lovely excerpt of Berry! I have been lucky to interact the past several years with others working on living inr ruaal place, and benefitting from the deep spiritual gifts of being attached to a particular place and the people who ended up there along with me; not the same as our ancestors who never traveled far, but still gratifying.

  2. mary mcguire says:

    thanks for the picture of the innocent blossom and thee quite clear comment from Berry. there are
    ommunities of people inside of corporations and cities like New Orleans: in both the lack of
    identification with each individual makes us take the few options that are apparent without looking
    for the one that is original and maybe a little harder, but better. One reason that happens is that
    we take our passion out of business and government. People are the answer, people in groups with
    their passion intact. mary

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s